Trader Joe’s Copycat Everything Bagel Cashews Recipe

A bold mix of flavors, savory with a touch of sweetness, these Everything Bagel Cashews will be your new favorite snack!

Have you heard of everything but the bagel seasoning? It has been a popular trend for the past few years and I started using it when it was first introduced by Trader Joe’s. It was so in demand that it was always sold out! I love to sprinkle it on my scrambled eggs and cream cheese with bacon. However, I had yet to try it on nuts until I discovered Trader Joe’s Everything Bagel Cashews. I created a simple copycat recipe for Everything Bagel Cashews and they are absolutely delicious. You should definitely give it a try!

Printable Recipe HERE

What is Everything Bagel Seasoning?

Everything But the Bagel seasoning is a delicious mix of familiar ingredients that tastes just like an everything bagel. The seasoning is made up of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, minced onion, minced garlic, and salt. All blended to create a fragrant seasoning that enhances the flavor of many dishes. You can sprinkle it on low-carb bagels, roast vegetables with it, or even use it as a dip seasoning, which I highly recommend!

Ingredients and Substitutions

Whole Cashews – This recipe is made with cashews, but you can substitute a variety of nuts. Almonds, peanuts, pecans or mixed nuts would all be great options! Make sure to use unsalted nuts because the seasoning is salty.

Avocado oil – Olive oil will work as well.

Everything bagel seasoning – You can use store-bought or homemade seasoning. Most grocery stores now carry this popular seasoning.

Brown sugar substitute – Adds a slight sweetness to the savory flavor of the nuts. I recommend the brown sugar substitute because of its depth of flavor. However, you can easily leave the sweetener out of the recipe.

How to Make Everything Bagel Cashews

Step 1

Preheat the oven to 325 degrees. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

Step 2

Put all of the ingredients in a large bowl. Stir to coat the cashews in the oil and seasonings.

Step 3

Spread the cashews in an even layer on the sheet pan. Bake the cashews in the oven, stirring every 10 minutes, for 20-25 minutes. Keep a close eye on them, not to burn. They’ll be golden brown. Allow them to cool completely before serving.

Serving Suggestions

Here are a few more ways to make the most use of this Everything Bagel Cashews Recipe:

• Charcuterie Board – Add a touch of uniqueness to your charcuterie board by adding Everything Bagel Cashews alongside an assortment of meats, cheeses, and berries. The savory and nutty flavor of the cashews pairs wonderfully with the other elements of the board.
• Salad Topping – Sprinkle a handful of Everything Bagel Cashews on your favorite salad to add a crunch. They make a great alternative to croutons!
• Trail Mix – Combine Everything Bagel Cashews with other nuts, seeds, and unsweetened coconut to create a customized trail mix. It’s a perfect snack for outdoor adventures or an on-the-go travel snack!

Storage Instructions

To maintain the freshness and flavor of your Everything Bagel Cashews, follow these storage instructions:

• Transfer the cashews to an airtight container, such as a zip lock bag or a glass jar with a lid.
• Store the cashews in a cool and dry place, away from direct sunlight and sources of heat—ideally, a pantry or cupboard for storage.
• While it is not necessary, refrigerating your Everything Bagel Cashews in an airtight container can help prolong their shelf life.