Hands Off Your Kid’s Trick-or-Treat Candy! Try these 9 Sugar-Free Options Instead

This post may contain affiliate links.

Halloween is that time of year when your kids’ candy stash beckons, and resisting it can be a challenge. Some parents even jokingly refer to it as the “candy tax.” Here are 9 sugar-free alternatives to enjoy festivities with your children, such as chocolate, flavorful suckers, and homemade Reese’s bars.

Lilys Candy Coated Pieces

Lilys candy on store shelf. There are several flavors.
Credit: Natasha.

Lily’s chocolate caramels offer a tasty alternative to Milk Duds, while Lily’s candy-coated pieces provide a sugar-free option to satisfy your craving for M&M’s.

Russel Stover Caramels

Bags of sugar free chocolate and caramel candy hanging from a hook on store shelf.
Credit: Natasha.

Russell Stover’s chocolate-covered caramels are a tasty sugar-free treat, combining creamy caramel with smooth chocolate.

Lilys Peanut Butter Cups

Lily’s peanut butter cups are a fantastic Reese’s alternative for peanut butter cup lovers. These sugar-free treats offer a guilt-free way to savor the perfect combination of creamy peanut butter and rich chocolate.

Lilys Candy Bars

Lily's candy bars on grocery shelf.
Credit: Natasha.

Lily’s candy bars are low carb and have no sugar added in many delicious flavors, including dark chocolate, milk chocolate, and specialty options like salted almond and coconut.

Zero Sugar Lollipops

Sugar free suckers on a store shelf.
Credit: Natasha

Sugar-free lollipops are a delightful and long-lasting flavor of lollipops without sugar, they are zero sugar, keto and vegan.

Werthers Caramels

Werthers sugar free candy on store shelf.
Credit: Natasha.

Werther’s Sugar-Free Caramel Candy provides the same rich and creamy caramel experience as their traditional counterparts but with a sugar-free recipe, making them a good option.

Keto Taffy

Bags of keto taffy on a store shelf.
Credit: Natasha.

Sugar-free taffy is a chewy candy that delivers all the classic taffy goodness without the sugar, perfect for those mindful of their sweet indulgences.

Sugar Free Gummy Worms

Sugar free gummy bears on store shelf.
Credit: Natasha.

Sugar-free gummy bears offer the sweet and chewy goodness of traditional gummies without the added sugar, making them a guilt-free treat for those watching their sugar intake.

Reese’s Cups Alternative

Sugar free peanut butter chocolate bars
Credit: Natasha.

Make your own treat, these delicious Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Chocolate Bars will satisfy your craving for Reese’s Cups!

Low Carb at Trader Joe’s

Front of building at Trader Joe's.
Credit: Natasha.

27 amazing Low Carb and Keto Finds at Trader Joe’s

Low Carb at Costco

Costco lettering on building outside the costco warehouse store.
Credit: Deposit photos.

OVER 50 amazing Low Carb and Keto Finds at Costco

Low Carb at Aldi

Aldi grocery store.
Credit: Deposit photos.

25 Great Low Carb and Keto Finds at ALDI

Low Carb at Sam’s Club

Sam's Club Sign outside the store.
Credit: Natasha.

30 Fantastic Low Carb and Keto Finds at Sam’s Club

Low Carb at Publix

Front of building at Publix grocery store.
Credit: Deposit Photos.

25 Incredible Low Carb and Keto Finds at Publix

 | Website

Author: Natasha Newton (Natasha's Southern Flavor)
Natasha is the founder of Natasha’s Southern Flavor. She has a passion for sharing delicious family friendly low-carb recipes that are easy to make and use readily accessible ingredients. Natasha has published three bestselling cookbooks. Her books and recipes have been featured by CNET, Delish, Mindbodygreen, Parade and Women’s Health. She enjoys traveling and spending time with her husband, two adult children, and three furbabies.
Read more about Natasha here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *